Monday, March 12, 2018

I served on a murder case for 8 days. Here’s my verdict on what it’s like to be a juror and my experiences.

I served on a murder case for 8 days. Here’s my verdict on what it’s like to be a juror.


Day 1
Process of Elimination
  Day one started by shuffling through security at 7:15am. Once through security we were directed to
the jury common area where all jurors were situated waiting for the judge to appear and lay out the
specific cases for the day. There are civil cases which can last 1-3 days and other cases which could
last a bit longer. This particular judge in question came down to address all jurors situated in the
holding area. He explained there were several cases that were taking place that day, and one specific
case he was working on for the next 8 days which was a murder trial. He then proceeded to tell us
that they were going to be choosing the jury for that murder trial that day. I just happened to be one
of the jurors that they randomly selected to fill out a brief survey attached to a clipboard. They asked
questions regarding the case, more specifically, a list of witnesses which we had to indicate whether
we knew. We had to answer other questions like if we knew anybody in law enforcement? If we had
known anybody in the past who was murdered? If the sensitive material presented in this case would
hinder our ability in any way to be a non-partial juror. After we were finished filling out the survey we
were instructed to form an line and meet outside the main common juror area, at which time, they
would give us a slip of paper to return at a specific time later on in the day. My specific ticket indicated
that I would need to return at 1pm to stand before the lawyers and judge to be questioned.
The time I was called back to appear before the courts was not the time they received me and the
other fifty jurors. We ended up waiting on the fourth floor lobby for about 35-45 minutes before we
were called into the courtroom. The bailiff came out each time, first asking for individuals the lawyers
had questions for based on their answers to the questionnaire, and then called us all into the back of
the courtroom to be seated and sworn in by the judge. At this time, before we sit, we are all instructed
to raise our right hand and make an oath to the judge that we solemnly swear under the penalty of
perjury that we swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Everyone have to say
I do out loud before the proceedings can go any further. After we’re sworn in, they called exactly 38
jurors from the back of the courtroom to proceed up front to be seated in the juror chairs and
additional folding chairs that were placed directly in front of the juror’s chairs. I was not one of
the first 38 people called, but it was still my duty, and the duty of every other jurors who were not
called, to listen to all proceedings in detail to make sure if somebody was dismissed that we’d have
the knowledge that they would have to answer questions if the lawyers were to call on you later.
Both lawyers in this situation were asking very specific hypothetical questions based on scenarios
they came up with. We learn later that these, although hypothetical questions, had a major priority
in this case which we were dealing with. At first, being a juror in the back of the courtroom, I thought
that I would be safe from being called up to the front. Oh boy was I wrong. After the first 3 jurors were
excused due to their answers to these hypothetical questions, which I’ll get to in a minute, I was then
the first of the next three people to be called up to sit in the juror’s box. The prosecution proceeded
to ask me if I had been paying attention to the questions asked, and if I could answer the hypothetical
question that was asked earlier. I’ll now ask you, the reader, the questions the prosecuting attorney
asked us while we were in the stand . . .
I want you to imagine a bank robbery, just your typical bank robbery maybe one you’ve seen in
a movie. There are four bank robbers one driving the getaway car, one standing watch at the door to
make sure that no cops are coming, and two other bank robbers carrying out the crime. The two
robbers holding up the bank inside are both holding guns. They are both pointing those guns at the
bank tellers telling them to give them money. Are you picturing that? One bank teller in particular
does not like what is going on and he decides to be a hero. He steps out from behind the counter
to try and grab the gun from one of the robbers, and they are now interacting in a physical altercation.
The robber shoots the teller to get him to stop and now the bank teller is lying on the floor dead.
Are you picturing this? The lawyer goes on to explain a specific law in Colorado called Felony Murder.
In the state of Colorado if a person or persons are trying to commit robbery they can and may be
tried for murder because they are both engaging in acts of a violent and dangerous nature.
This law specifically states that if you engaged in a harmful dangerous act and murder occurs
whether you were the one who killed an individual or not you are still held liable for that murder
if you were participating in this act. So not only would bank robber 1 who shot the individual be held
liable for murder but all 3 accomplices in the crime as well, robber number 2, number 3, and number 4. She asked pretty much every juror she spoke with if they would be okay carrying out that law specifically in this situation, again trying each one for murder, if that’s what the law stated, and if they would have a problem following that law? Each juror answered in their own words whether they could or could not follow that law and what they thought about this specific hypothetical in question. There were too many responses to go over in this blog. After the prosecution asked this specific question and jurors answered honestly, people started to get dismissed. After the first 3 jurors were dismissed my name was called.
They then asked me to give my opinions on the specific scenario at hand. After all 3 new jurors were
questioned the defending attorney asked his hypothetical which was, “Do you think that a person
who is under the influence or impaired cannot claim self defense? Ask yourself this question as well
please? That is when the first days’ court proceedings were finished and they dismissed us for the day. We had to show up the next day at 8:30am to begin to be questioning further.


Day 2


After all people gave their opinions to the questions they now did what is called perfunctory
challenges. The defending and prosecuting attorney’s both got to eliminate 12 people of their
choosing from the panel of jurors. I’ll be honest, during this time I was hoping they would call
my name, but they didn’t. After a total of 24 people had been dismissed from the panel I was
one of the 12 jurors and 2 alternates selected. They don’t tell you who the alternates are until
the end of the trail. The alternates are selected at random and only step in when another juror
in incapable of fulling his duty. The alternates get revealed after the closing statements have
been made. Once the jurors were selected and told you which juror they were, in this case I
as juror #3, the rest of the jury which was seated in the back was dismissed from the rest of
the trial. We then took another oath in front of the judge and the trial began. They did not
waste any time. After we sat down being sworn in for the second time, both sides gave their
opening statements and the trial began. I was shocked at how quick that actually was. I was
thinking they would dismiss us for the day and we’d come back the next day and start the trial,
but it just didn’t work that way. After opening statements, witnesses began to be called.
The first day was mostly details about people who were close to the victim. What problems he
struggled with, such as substance abuse, violence, family issues. They called up neighbors
who lived next to where the crime took place. They showed the victims body in the car from
several different angles as he was found dead, contorted and stuffed into the back of his own
SUV.
  Again this was just day 1-2. I'll go over the rest of the jury duty in the next posts.


--S

No comments:

Post a Comment